Navigation to Home, Links, and Contact info Link to Home Link to Links Link to Contact info
Wisconsin Clearinghouse Logo and link to home page  
blank

Prevention

Youth Development Programs Underage Drinking

Advocacy

Resources  
   
      Calendars Evaluation Data & Statistics News Wisconsin State Prevention Conference Funding        
Historical Overview
Introduction
Prevention: What Is It?
Evidence-Based Prevention
Building Blocks for Prevention
Environmental Strategies
Coalition Building
Alcohol & Other Drugs
Tools for Prevention

Rating Criteria
for Evidence-Based Programs

 

  1. Theory: the degree at which programs reflect clear principles about substance abuse behavior and how it can be changed.

  2. Intervention Fidelity: how the program ensures consistent delivery.

  3. Process Evaluation: whether the program implementation was measured.

  4. Sampling Strategy and Implementation: how well the program selected its participants and how well they received it.

  5. Attrition: whether the program retained participants during evaluation.

  6. Outcome Measures: the relevance and quality of evaluation measures.

  7. Missing Data: how developers addressed incomplete measurements.

  8. Data Collection: the manner in which data were gathered.

  9. Analysis: the appropriateness and technical adequacy of data analyses.

  10. Other Plausible Threats to Validity: the degree to which the evaluation considers other explanations for program effects.

  11. Replications: number of times the program has been used in the field.

  12. Dissemination Capability: whether program materials are ready for implementation by others in the field.

  13. Cultural/ Age Appropriateness: the degree to which the program addresses different ethnic-racial and age groups.

  14. Integrity: overall level of confidence of the scientific rigor of the evaluation.

  15. Utility: overall pattern of program findings to inform prevention theory and practice.

 

[Scoring a Model Program]

[Selecting a Model Program]

[Core Components of a Model Program]

[Matrix of Available Model Programs]